Draft chapter 168: Landscaping and Tree Standards

§ 168.05 Preservation Of Existing Trees

The 2026 draft's § 168.05 beside the current code's Zoning § 16.06: removed words are struck through, added words underlined.

Comparison with a draft: not adopted. The archive holds no public hearing, ordinance or vote adopting the recodified Code through the October 20, 2026 meeting packet. Until one is adopted, every page here compares the consolidated code with a draft that can still change: the revised draft with the October 6 changes is not in the archive.

A comparison with the August 2026 draft recodification prepared by Iowa Codification for the City. The draft has not been adopted and can still change; the current code (unofficial compilation) governs until a recodified Code is adopted. Matches between sections are made by machine from the texts and are reviewed where uncertain.

Renumbered or moved wording changed (86% same words)

Notable changes

  • Amount or number: …<th>Diameter Of Existing Tree<br>(Measured 4 Feet Above Ground Level)</th> <th>Substitution Value</th> </tr> <tr> <td>36 Level) 36 inches or more</td> <td>3 required trees</td> </tr> <tr>…
  • Amount or number: …Level)</th> <th>Substitution Value</th> </tr> <tr> <td>36 inches or more</td> <td>3 more 3 required trees</td> </tr> <tr> <td>12-35 inches</td> <td>2 required…
  • Amount or number: …</tr> <tr> <td>36 inches or more</td> <td>3 required trees</td> </tr> <tr> <td>12-35 inches</td> <td>2 trees 12-35 inches 2 required trees</td> </tr> <tr> <td>2-12 inches</td> <td>1 required…
  • Amount or number: …required trees</td> </tr> <tr> <td>12-35 inches</td> <td>2 required trees</td> </tr> <tr> <td>2-12 inches</td> <td>1 trees 2-12 inches 1 required tree</td> </tr> </table> Note: 1. The substitution…

What changed

Existing trees may be used to comply with the requirements of subsections 16.07, "Street Tree Requirements", Subsections 168.06 and 16.08, "Tree Requirements for Residential Uses", of this section. 168.07. Existing trees used to satisfy these requirements must shall be in good health prior to and following site development. The City Designee designee is authorized to approve substitutions based on determination of health and survivability. Table 16-2, "Schedule of Substitution Values", of this section, will The table in Subsection 6 shall be used to determine the ratio of substitution. The following provisions must shall also be observed:
A. 1. The same minimum separation distances that are required of new plantings must shall be observed when possible; except, that extant groupings of two (2) or more trees may be preserved upon approval by the City Designee, designee, who will also determine if trees or branches must shall be removed from such groupings in the interest of public safety and/or or to assure survival of the specimen.
B. 2. The building official Building Official will determine if a preserved tree will be a substitute for a street tree or a residential use tree, depending on its location on a lot.
C. 3. The roots of a tree must shall be protected during site development with barrier fencing extending out at least as far as the drip line of the tree, or as far as the City Designee designee deems necessary to minimize damage. Any limbs that might be damaged during construction must shall be pruned according to the direction of the City Designee. designee.
D. 4. No paving or construction will shall be allowed within the drip line of a preserved tree.
E. 5. Any preserved tree that dies within five (5) years of the issuance of a certificate of occupancy must shall be replaced by the same number of trees for which it substituted.
Table 16-2: 6. Schedule of Substitution Values
<table> <tr> <th>Diameter
1 Diameter Of Existing Tree<br>(Measured Tree Substitution Value (Measured 4 Feet Above Ground Level)</th> <th>Substitution Value</th> </tr> <tr> <td>36 Level) 36 inches or more</td> <td>3 more 3 required trees</td> </tr> <tr> <td>12 trees 12 to 35 inches</td> <td>2 inches 2 required trees</td> </tr> <tr> <td>2 trees 2 to 12 inches</td> <td>1 inches 1 required tree</td> </tr> </table>
Note:
1.
tree The substitution value of groupings of 1 one or more trees, provided their preservation as a group is approved by the City Designee, designee, will be based on the caliper measure of the largest tree of the group.

Word-level comparison of the current text with the draft's; spacing and paragraph breaks come from the documents' text. Footnotes are left out.

Current code

Zoning § 16.06 Preservation Of Existing Trees

Existing trees may be used to comply with the requirements of subsections 16.07, "Street Tree Requirements", and 16.08, "Tree Requirements for Residential Uses", of this section. Existing trees used to satisfy these requirements must be in good health prior to and following site development. The City Designee is authorized to approve substitutions based on determination of health and survivability. Table 16-2, "Schedule of Substitution Values", of this section, will be used to determine the ratio of substitution. The following provisions must also be observed:

A. The same minimum separation distances that are required of new plantings must be observed when possible; except, that extant groupings of two (2) or more trees may be preserved upon approval by the City Designee, who will also determine if trees or branches must be removed from such groupings in the interest of public safety and/or to assure survival of the specimen.

B. The building official will determine if a preserved tree will be a substitute for a street tree or a residential use tree, depending on its location on a lot.

C. The roots of a tree must be protected during site development with barrier fencing extending out at least as far as the drip line of the tree, or as far as the City Designee deems necessary to minimize damage. Any limbs that might be damaged during construction must be pruned according to the direction of the City Designee.

D. No paving or construction will be allowed within the drip line of a preserved tree.

E. Any preserved tree that dies within five (5) years of the issuance of a certificate of occupancy must be replaced by the same number of trees for which it substituted.

Table 16-2: Schedule of Substitution Values

<table> <tr> <th>Diameter Of Existing Tree<br>(Measured 4 Feet Above Ground Level)</th> <th>Substitution Value</th> </tr> <tr> <td>36 inches or more</td> <td>3 required trees</td> </tr> <tr> <td>12 to 35 inches</td> <td>2 required trees</td> </tr> <tr> <td>2 to 12 inches</td> <td>1 required tree</td> </tr> </table>

Note:

1. The substitution value of groupings of 1 or more trees, provided their preservation as a group is approved by the City Designee, will be based on the caliper measure of the largest tree of the group.

Ord. 2017-394 · source page

2026 draft

§ 168.05 Preservation Of Existing Trees

Existing trees may be used to comply with the requirements of Subsections 168.06 and 168.07. Existing trees used to satisfy these requirements shall be in good health prior to and following site development. The City designee is authorized to approve substitutions based on determination of health and survivability. The table in Subsection 6 shall be used to determine the ratio of substitution. The following provisions shall also be observed:

1. The same minimum separation distances that are required of new plantings shall be observed when possible; except, that extant groupings of two or more trees may be preserved upon approval by the City designee, who will also determine if trees or branches shall be removed from such groupings in the interest of public safety or to assure survival of the specimen.

2. The Building Official will determine if a preserved tree will be a substitute for a street tree or a residential use tree, depending on its location on a lot.

3. The roots of a tree shall be protected during site development with barrier fencing extending out at least as far as the drip line of the tree, or as far as the City designee deems necessary to minimize damage. Any limbs that might be damaged during construction shall be pruned according to the direction of the City designee.

4. No paving or construction shall be allowed within the drip line of a preserved tree.

5. Any preserved tree that dies within five years of the issuance of a certificate of occupancy shall be replaced by the same number of trees for which it substituted.

6. Schedule of Substitution Values 1 Diameter Of Existing Tree Substitution Value (Measured 4 Feet Above Ground Level) 36 inches or more 3 required trees 12 to 35 inches 2 required trees 2 to 12 inches 1 required tree The substitution value of groupings of one or more trees, provided their preservation as a group is approved by the City designee, will be based on the caliper measure of the largest tree of the group.

August 2026 draft · page 643

Back to draft chapter 168 · All changes

Data last updated October 22, 2026. Built from the archive's documents; see how the data is built.